White Daisies

1980, Chicago

By Elizabeth Sandoval

Twenty-something years after we traded stickers on the playground and revealed our secret crushes while running laps in P.E., we were an attorney, a teacher, an actor, a graphic designer, a mom. And now that we were all grown up with our grown-up set of life challenges, one lofty innovator (the attorney) launched a monthly “Challenge Meeting.”

We were to meet to discuss how we were chipping away at our year-long individual challenges. Some seemed more daunting than others. To an outsider, the challenge of “Step into your greatness” may have appeared to be more trying than “Lose some weight.” But, relative to the unique paths we’d chosen for our lives, they all bore the same weight (so to speak).

This particular year bore some heavy ones: “Where is there room in your life for forgiveness?” “Stop making excuses.” And the one that would subsequently blast open the doors of my mind that had been vaulted shut for 25 years: “What decision have you been avoiding making that could change the course of your life?”

She was a girl of about 7 years old. Loved to laugh and loved to be around those who were laughing. Loved her family. Loved hanging around with the neighborhood girls, who were more like sisters than pals. It was not just about lending someone a cup of sugar, but actually giving it to her. Not just knowing about the people next door or two doors down, but actually knowing them. Seasons came and went, and once-neighbors became great friends.

On this particular day, she wore a blue terry cloth spaghetti-strapped dress. There were white daisies with yellow centers dangling from the fringe along the top. It was a nice dress. And she wore it to her friend Tina’s house on this, oh, probably summer day. She frequented the house often. Her family and Tina’s family were like, well, family.

In subsequent years, they would spend every Easter together. Every Thanksgiving together. Every Christmas together. Throw in a random “Godmother” or “Bridesmaid” title and you begin to see how intertwined their lives were. Her family held Tina’s family on a pedestal. “Such nice people” (or something to that effect) was a usual utterance from the mouths of her mother or father.

So imagine her shock and dismay when, after a period of playing with Tina on this day, she somehow found herself in the bedroom of Tina’s parents. With Tina’s father, more specifically, who was taking it upon himself to push her to the ground and kiss her forcefully.

She doesn’t remember how she got to his room. But there he was in all his greatness, projecting his manly weight onto this girl in her terry cloth dress. To this day, the feeling of rough whiskers pressed against her mouth can make her shudder, and she’s yet to kiss a man with a bonafide moustache. But we’ll save those issues for later.

Imagine this girl’s confusion when this man who was present at her parents’ dinner table for the celebration of Christ’s birth or Resurrection was now making his presence known so violently. It lasted a matter of seconds. Maybe not quite a minute. There was a struggle to get away, of course. Or at least moving away from the coarseness of the facial hair, which up to that point had only been felt in the form of stubble from her loving dad planting a peck on her cheek.

And then Tina walked in, changing the course of this girl’s fate. For when his eyes beheld his own Tina at that moment, he relented in his pursuit of this girl. But the damage, as they say, had been done.

And so their lives continued to be intertwined. There were birthday celebrations and strawberry festivals and dance lessons and ice skating and whatever else entices a girl of about 7 and then suddenly 17 and then 27. For the years passed and the friendship continued. And interspersed in the myriad Judy Blume moments of her youth and then young adulthood and adult adulthood, there was an anxiousness that had grown to a fear and then to a panic and then to a paralysis.

She had made no connection between the terry cloth dress moment and the irrational fears that had taken up residence in her mind. No sleepovers at friends’ houses for this girl. No, no. What if something “bad” happened and she couldn’t get home? No sleeping by herself in her room, either. Too many scary noises. It’s best to be near someone in case someone tries to get you in the middle of the night. And if you’re gonna say “Good night,” make sure you say it 10 or 20 or, heck, 50 times, to make sure your parents really hear you.

It may seem weird in the morning, but in the thick of it, it’s gotta be done. Don’t let the anxiety back in. Do this and then do that and you’ll be fine. Rinse your mouth 25 times if you have to. Do what you gotta do to keep from freaking out, for then the whole world, or at least your family, will know that something is horribly wrong with you.

So emotions were shelved, fears temporarily thwarted, and by the grace of God, a life was lived. Half-lived, really. But she wouldn’t know that for years to come. This private hell in her mind was not enough to stomp out all of the life in her. Awards were won. For spelling or speech or writing or this or that. Accolades were bestowed. Memories emblazoned. She defied anyone to look into her vibrant hazel eyes and find disorder or pain. She laughed abundantly, not in an attempt to cover the tears. But because there were so many moments of tears that she welcomed laughter. The laughter was always real and not fake. It was treasured beyond words.

She had been born in Chicago and had yearned to one day go back. A plethora of Chicago postcards and posters covered her bedroom walls. And while she spent years being too imprisoned to actually venture physically to Chicago, she went many a time in her mind. Over time, some of the fears became dormant and she felt that she had been healed marginally – at least to the point of not being paralyzed. And so she returned to Chicago. And she explored and worked and took in all that the city had to offer.

Was there anything better than waking up to the sight of Lake Michigan and the Chicago skyline? Or walking along the Chicago River and taking in the smells and sounds of life all around her? Or being at an art museum one moment and listening to the symphony the next?

There was a real love in her heart for this city. And human love had not yet arrived at her doorstep. There were invitations to false intimacy — with a guy or a male — but not a “man” in the true sense of the word. She wanted something better for herself than a person who smoked this or that and drank this or that and partied insatiably and wanted sex. She didn’t want that.

And at the same time, she feared finding someone who would truly listen to her, who would find her sexy despite the extra 20 pounds on her frame, who would be excited about and not afraid of her goals and her likes and her dislikes and her needs — and
her fears. For if she ever found someone like that, why on earth would he want to be with someone like her? A heart full of gold, but a head full of coal. Heavy and dark. Too scary to let herself sort through — let alone let somebody else. A “Damaged Goods” label was permanently, albeit invisibly, placed on her forehead.

Sure, she would fret and whine with the best of them about not being able to find a “good man,” and why she was spending Valentine’s Day alone, and all of that good stuff. But the truth of the matter is that while she yearned to find him, she was terrified of finding him all the same.

For isn’t it enough to know for yourself that you’re crazy? Do you really need someone else getting close enough to find that out for himself? No, life had served up some wilted vegetables. And she would just have to make a salad out of them — and eat it all by herself.

Her life was a circus of thoughts. One day suicidal, the next full of hope. One day disillusioned by the elusiveness of wellness, the next optimistic about having a full recovery. Too fearful to ever seek professional help, but in desperate need of it. She had visited a psychiatrist once or twice in years past. The anticipation of knowing whether she was crazy or not led her to the office of one doctor who reassured her, “You’re not crazy.” What a relief. She could then re-shelve her emotions and move on with her “life.” Again.

Enter her childhood friends. All grown up now in the 21st century, with the challenge, “What decision have you been avoiding making that could change the course of your life?” And like a lightbulb going off in that dark mind of hers, she knew what decision she had been avoiding making. The decision to stop pondering the pain for isolated moments and then putting it back on a shelf.

It was terrifying and freeing all the same as she wrote her friends this oh-so-unordinary e-mail from Chicago. An e-mail detailing not what the weather was like in Chicago, or inquiring as to how the kids were doing, but what had truly lived in her mind for the past 25 years. Introducing them for the first time to this person they thought they already knew.

They embraced her from 2,000 miles away, and life has not been the same since. For once the darkness is brought into the light, the demons of your mind can no longer have their way with you. And people, like angels, rush to your side. They keep silent if you want them to. They hold your hand. And they lay witness as you unleash the burdens that have been holding their own monthly meeting in your soul for most of your life.

This girl has yet to tell her parents. So Tina’s dad remains on that pedestal. And the holiday gatherings continue. There’s a big one coming up at the end of this month, as you know. For the first time in her life, this girl will not attend. And she is contemplating finally telling her parents. All these years, she has feared hurting her mom profoundly. She has feared the repercussions amongst Tina’s family - what it would mean for her parents’ marriage, their family bonds, and even him. But as a friend told this girl recently, “HE deserves to carry that burden now. You have carried it alone for 25 years.” This girl has forgiven Tina’s dad. But she no longer feels contemptuous by agreeing that this pain is his responsibility now.

Tina and the girl have never spoken of this incident. In fact, for one reason or another, she does not communicate much with her anymore (though the family meetings continue). She’s come back from Chicago, and has managed to avoid contact with Tina’s entire family. She visited a counselor in Chicago, who reassured her that these behaviors and thoughts throughout the years were typical for someone who was abused as a child. “Order, as you knew it, was destroyed,” she said, “and so you attempt to restore that order. You create your own.”

And that looks different for everyone. Maybe you rinse your mouth 25 times. Maybe you say “Good night” 50 times. Yes, you need to be helped. “But you’re not crazy.”

I am not crazy.

Elizabeth Sandoval, a Chicago native, currently resides in Whittier, California. Her work has been published in The Los Angeles Times, Newsweek, USA Today, The Los Angeles Daily News, San Gabriel Valley Tribune, and on Chicago Public Radio.

Posted by Elizabeth Armstrong Moore on Friday, November 10th, 2006 | Email This Post

This entry was posted on Friday, November 10th, 2006 at 12:03 am. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

7 Responses to “White Daisies”

  1. Jolie Says:

    What a startling story and a beautiful writer who composed it. Your vulnerability should be heralded and your strength, revered. Thank you for sharing. You couldn’t sound less crazy if you tried.

  2. J. Hall Says:

    Sandoval,

    It\’s terribly sad that you let this eat at you for so long. You parents would probably want to know, despite the repercussions.

    On top of that, I wonder if you were the only one. I recall a certain friend of mine that lived next door to Tina who was a textbook case of OCD (sure, it could be completely unrelated) and I wonder where she is now and how she’d react to your blog.

    For the record, I had a similar experience and was forced into a terribly awkward family meeting/confrontation, long before I was ready. When dealing with events loaded with such emotion, no one walks away unscathed and no one has the right words to say. The term “unspeakable” is part of our language for a reason. Such confrontations are never ideal and always ugly but perhaps just exposing things to the open air is all that’s required.

    It’s probably best to get over with before that holiday turkey is on the table. Why let someone who doesn’t deserve a seat at your family dinners scare you off!

    We’re all incredibly f***ed up but without the bitter how would we ever appreciate the sweet? I REALLY appreciate the sweet! You’ve made me laugh more times than I can count and I hope whatever you do, you don’t forget to save for yourself a portion of that forgiveness.

    With love,
    J

  3. ben Says:

    the power of forgiveness is a magical thing. the products of which include a release, a refocus, and most importantly a beginning. i truly understand your words and am thankful that you where able to eventually find the “play” button, and press it. love, ben

  4. Elizabeth Sandoval Says:

    hi, j (and anyone else who may have read my essay).

    i have not yet written “Part 2.”

    but it would detail how last year, i finally told my parents (and tina’s parents) of this ordeal.

    tina’s parents subsequently divorced and sold their house. for a brief while, i grappled with guilt. feeling “responsible” for having torn that family apart.

    but i reminded myself that it had been HIS actions to ultimately tear them apart. for actions always have momentum–no matter if it takes 25 years to see the end result.

    i pray for their individual restoration.

    thank you for reading.

    -elizabeth

  5. Jennifer Dickinson Says:

    Hi Elizabeth,
    I’m sure it has been a relief to share your story. There are so many young girls and women who go through this, remaining silent for fear that they are the ones at fault. You may help someone grappling with this issue.
    With your follow up post about Tina’s parents’ divorce, perhaps this revelation was the icing on the cake. Sounds like you were not the first and probably not the last to have been violated by him. If the case, it probably added to their decision to divorce. Glad you are no longer living with the guilt of that one on top of what you’ve already experienced…it was probably long in the works before you shared what happened.
    God Bless,
    Jennifer D

  6. Elizabeth Sandoval Says:

    Thank you, everyone, for your support!

  7. Diego R. Rodriguez Says:

    Dear Ms. Sandoval,

    I am having a world of a hard time trying to locate your email to repond to your NPR History 101 on the \”Hyphenated-American.\” First, I hope you directly get this, since this is meant for you to read. Second, I have never heard of you until your piece on NPR and you delivered a powerful piece. Third, we share the same neighborhood, Chicago…….So, I hope you will reply to this.

    I strongly believe that much of what you voiced as your opinion, position, and perhaps, what you believe to be true, holds a lot of weight in reason. There are many Americans of Hispanic origin, to use this as an example, who do not know their ethnic origin\’s history; yet, many are proud to be \”whatever\” which they also treat their \”US citizenship\” as a second-class or disregard it. It is one of the most disturbing ongoing problem among many Hispanics.

    This is why I do not like the terms \”Hispanic or Latino.\” I was born in Chicago and that makes me an American. I am not going to \”Hyphenate\” any thing, nothing. I am also equally aware or conscientious of what my family\’s history means, insofar as what they told me growing up, what research I have invested in reading about my parent\’s homeland, Panama. But I am not Panamanian, nor is Panamanian my nationality. I am first and foremost an American.

    I thank you for your voice. I am sure there will be many who may differ, and this may and probably will come in many emotional forms, feelings, sense a collective identity due to their parents origin. The \”generic\” American example that you used is one that I am divided. Sure, I am aware of Americans who came from the \”other America,\” and what many of our families have gone through insofar as struggle to be treated equally, but, I believe we must struggle to be who we are and not how others define who we are. If others treat us as \”uequal,\” we have to remind others that we are also Americans, regardless of race, ethnic origin, religion.

    Thank You,
    Mr. Rodriguez
    Chicago, Illinois

Leave a Reply

NOTE: Please submit your comment only once. It will have to be approved by the administrator before it is posted.

Visual Captcha